Whey Protein... Yay, or nay?

Former Member
Former Member
I'm getting back into swimming and was wondering if whey protein is appropriate before and after a workout in the pool. I'm in the Army, so I also need to work on my running, sit-ups, and push-ups and whey has helped me with the lifting (which I don't plan on giving up). Any suggestions? Or should I revamp my nutrition plan. Right now I'm consuming a lot of protein and saturated fat, and low sugars and carbs (except fiber). Thanks! -Jared
  • Detour bars, especially the "low sugar" varietys seem to be a good source. 30g iirc.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    The typical American diet has more than enough protein. Some research suggests athletes have higher requirements than the U.S. RDA, and suggests the figure of 1.2-1.4 g/kg body weight per day. I've heard of people who are trying to get huge consuming much larger amounts but that is not something I personally would try or would suggest anyone else try without consulting a physician or dietitian. For some people, it boils down to the convenience factor, whether you feel like grilling a chicken *** or drinking a glass of milk or juice with a scoop of protein powder.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    I'm getting back into swimming and was wondering if whey protein is appropriate before and after a workout in the pool. I'm in the Army, so I also need to work on my running, sit-ups, and push-ups and whey has helped me with the lifting (which I don't plan on giving up). Any suggestions? Or should I revamp my nutrition plan. Right now I'm consuming a lot of protein and saturated fat, and low sugars and carbs (except fiber). Thanks! -Jared Whey protein is a very good choice post-workout. Go with a casein protein source pre-workout with slow digesting carbs.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    The typical American diet has more than enough protein... Yes, and two things to keep in mind with a very high protein intake: - Your kidneys have to work hard to get rid of the excess, so you'll need to drink a lot of water. - To expell the the excess, your body binds it with calcium. So, if you're eating huge amounts of protein, you must also be consuming extra calcium to spare your bones.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    Yay to whey. I'm a retired Navy pilot. Beat Army. Actually - I hate football - I love swimming - so what do I care? Anywhey - I'm 45 and have tried to swim like I'm still in college for a while now. I found that whey after a hard workout makes it so the hard workout the next day is whey less painful.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    -Yay. -Use as breakfast/Meal #1 protein source & post-training shake. -Use an isolate whey protein with no artificial sweetners (sucralose, aspartame, acesulfame-potassium) or other chemicals. Most on the market (especially in the US) are loaded with these toxins so shop around.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    So its still alright if I go with the low carbs and low sugars when I do swimming? If anyone wants to know why I am doing this, it was a workout/diet plan from MensHealth. www.menshealth.com/.../article.do It emphasizes using stored fat for energy opposed to sugars.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    I need more stats to give more advice. Age, height, weight, date&score on last APFT, what score are you aiming for on your next test, etc. edit: I looked at your profile and see you're a chaplain assistant. Interesting. I'm curious what rank you are. I remember chaplains started at O-3 but I never met a chaplain assistant.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    What is the purpose low sugar low carbs???Weight loss? 30/30/40 some say 30 protein, 30 fat, 40 carbs. I have heard all kinds of numbers. We need all three to perform well.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    For people who tend to eat healthfully (lots of whole grains, fruits, veggies) it's easy not to get enough protein so I take whey. It's cheap and easy to digest. But read the ingredients CAREFULLY because they add lots of junk to it. I found this stuff, which seemed to be okay. Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Natural Whey