This thread is an expansion of Ande's Swimming Faster Faster Tip 31: Get Strong. This is where I give advice on how to get stronger for the purpose of swimming faster.
I'm an authority on this subject only in a limited sense. I'm not a swim coach or a strength coach. I made a lot of improvement in my swimming when I started lifting weights, and I've given advice to a few other people (swimmers and non-swimmers) on how to get started on strength training. I draw a lot on conventional strength training wisdom. That's general strength training, not strength training for swimming.
In my opinion, and this is probably the most radical theme I'm going to stick with here, strength training advice for swimmers has always sucked. It is most often some kind of perverted and watered down version of the strength training that actual strong people do. A lot of buzzwords get added (e.g., "functional") and actual weight (i.e., iron) gets subtracted. My number one principle for strength training is this: it's not swimming! Don't mimic strokes, don't worry about skills. Just get stronger. The strength will transfer.
Safety
I'm starting with this at Jim Thornton's suggestion. Your first priority in the weight room is to avoid getting hurt.
Joint pain
This is just like swimming. The rule is: if it hurts, don't do it. Tendonitis comes on slowly, and when you feel it, you should stop doing whatever exercise causes it. There are also rehab/prehab exercises for strength and flexibility targeting any joint you can think of.
Lower back
Some lifts, particularly squats and deadlifts, require you to bend over at the waist. Do these in a mirror where you can see your side profile whenever possible, or have somebody watch your form. You need to keep your lower back slightly arched at all times, never flexed while supporting a significant weight. Some techniques to promote good form are: looking up, trying to point your chest to the ceiling, and trying to push your butt backward. Use whatever combination of these cues work for you, and check your form visually.
Dropping weight
Common sense. Overhead weights are dangerous. Don't drop heavy stuff on your head. When doing any exercise, ask yourself what would happen if you suddenly passed out and collapsed. Would the weight hit you? Would it choke you? I'm not saying to avoid exercises like that, but be careful. End your sets before you start feeling shaky. Use stops on a power rack. Ask somebody to spot you (unless you are doing squats and you aren't good friends already). Again, this should really be common sense.
Muscle soreness
Sorry, this is not an injury. I just put it here to make sure nobody mistakes it for one :) It's going to happen, and it's probably going to be far more intense than what you get from swimming.
Exercise selection
Exercise selection is all about variety. It's important to strengthen all of the muscles on the body, and you can do that by focusing on three basic movements: push, pull, and squat. Do these basic movements at different angles and positions to strengthen the entire body. Choosing different grips and equipment can also keep you from getting bored with weight training, and it can prevent joint injuries.
Push
In pushing, the elbows straighten and move away from the body. The two basic angles for pushing are forward and upward. Here's the barbell bench press, a forward pushing movement:
YouTube - Instructional Fitness - Bench Press
And here's the standing barbell shoulder press, an upward pushing movement:
YouTube - Build Muscle: Barbell Shoulder Press
And of course there are different angles and hybrids. For example, incline bench press is in between shoulder press and bench press. Also, any of these things can be done with dumbbells or other equipment.
Pull
Pulling means elbows bend and come toward the body. The two basic angles for pulling are downward and backward. Here's the dumbbell row, a backward pulling movement:
YouTube - Instructional Fitness - One-arm Dumbbell Rows
And here's a pull-up, which is not just a downward pulling movement, but the downward pulling movement that all beginning lifters must do, because of all of the different muscles it stresses:
YouTube - dead-hang pull ups with 70lb kettlebell.AVI
Squat
The squatting movement is the basis for all lower body development. My favorite squatting movement is the barbell lunge, which puts less relative stress on the lower back by working one leg at a time:
YouTube - Lunges 225 X 7
If you bend over without bending much at the knees, squatting turns into a deadlift variation. Here's the sumo deadlift:
YouTube - How to Sumo Deadlift
Load, volume, and frequency
These are parameters you need to balance. Load means: how heavy is the weight? Or, more specifically: how much force are your muscles required to produce to move it? Volume means: how many repetitions do you do? How much total work are the muscles doing? Frequency means: how often does a particular muscle get worked? You can do a full-body workout three days a week, or maybe upper body two days a week and lower body one day. Or you can get even more specific. Bodybuilders like to have days like "chest", "arms", and "shoulders" over the course of a week.
I know this sounds arbitrary, but we have to start somewhere. Here are my can't-fail load and volume parameters for newbies:
1. Do a full body workout two or three days a week, involving one push, one pull, and one squat.
2. Do between 2 and 6 sets per exercise, excluding easy/warm-up sets.
3. Do between 5 and 15 reps per set.
4. Don't take less than a full minute of rest between sets.
Within that, knock yourself out. You'll eventually come to some kind of understanding of how you respond to different amounts of volume and load, and how much variety you want. In a bit I'll give you a specific program to start with, if that's too much choice for you.
Failure and fatigue
Fatigue means you start to shake or slow down. Failure means you are no longer able to lift the weight. In my opinion, these things are way overrated. It's fun to challenge yourself and see exactly how many reps you can do to failure, but if you are doing 30 reps of 135 pounds on some exercise, 3 sets of 10 is pretty much the same as 6 sets of 5. I often prefer to do the latter, although it might take slightly longer. It all depends on how much pain you want to be in. There are some minor strength benefits to failure in strength training, but it definitely doesn't have to happen on every set, or even in every workout. It's just another parameter that you can change depending on how you like it.
Introduction plan
This is a plan that follows my guidelines. It's very similar to what I did when I started lifting. The exercises in it are the ones I showed videos of above. If you have more questions about how to do them or set up for them, please ask.
This workout is built on sets of 10 reps. Choose a very light weight to start, and slowly add weight, never more than 20 pounds at a time (or 10 pounds per dumbbell) until you can't complete 10 reps on your last set. Once you learn roughly how much weight you can do on a particular exercise, you can choose a good point to start ramping up from without wasting time.
Workout A
Assisted pull-up machine (Remember, more weight is easier on this.)
Standing barbell shoulder press (Stop any set if you start to feel shaky. Don't go to failure on these!)
Barbell alternating lunge (You can also do this holding dumbbells at your side. Pretty much the same.)
Workout B
One-arm dumbbell row (Switch arms between sets, and stop when either arm fails to get 10 reps.)
Barbell bench press (Stop a bit short of failure, or get a spotter.)
Sumo deadlift (Check your lower back form! The set is over when you lose perfect form.)
Do Workout A, rest a few days, then do Workout B. Repeat. Take extra rest days if you feel like it. Feel free to substitute similar movements if you get bored or don't like the ones I prescribe.
Questions?
Ask me!
Here is my problem,too many years of doing stupid stuff has left me with lumbar disc problems.If I try to lift very much with like dead lifts or overhead presses my left leg goes numb.I can do pulley exercises and stability ball exercises fine.I want to increase my leg strength,which for a breaststroker is vital,but I seem to be stuck with using the machines for leg presses and leg curls.Any suggestions.
A couple years back I was doing a lot of overhead barbell presses and dropped about 2 seconds in the 50 *** (38.5 50m to 32.6 50 yd. in 6 months, I think that works out to about 2 seconds improvement after conversions). I think the overhead presses were a big part of it. I didn't go as fast this year due to some training breaks and maybe changes in weight training routine (changed to 3x/week split instead of full-body each time).
Here is my problem,too many years of doing stupid stuff has left me with lumbar disc problems.If I try to lift very much with like dead lifts or overhead presses my left leg goes numb.I can do pulley exercises and stability ball exercises fine.I want to increase my leg strength,which for a breaststroker is vital,but I seem to be stuck with using the machines for leg presses and leg curls.Any suggestions.
What about extreme angle isometrics? I've done these sporadically -- an extreme angle squat, extreme angle lunge, and an extreme angle step up on a box. The first two you do without weights until you get to 5:00 and then you add weight. The last one you do with DBs on a fairly high box with one foot on the box and only the toe of the other foot on the ground. You only use the lead leg to pull you up; I've heard these are better than single leg squats for increasing leg strength. I like to do the extreme angle isometric squat followed by overhead squats and squat jumps with a bar.
Here's a study on the topic:
Extreme Angle Isometrics:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/.../entrez
Changes in torque and electromyographic activity of the quadriceps femoris muscles following isometric training.Bandy WD, Hanten WP.
Department of Physical Therapy, University of Central Arkansas, Conway 72035-0001.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE. The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of isometric training of the quadriceps femoris muscles, at different joint angles, on torque production and electromyographic (EMG) activity. SUBJECTS. One hundred seven women were randomly assigned to one of four groups. Three groups trained with isometric contractions three times per week at a knee flexion angle of 30, 60, or 90 degrees. The fourth group, which served as a control, did not exercise. METHODS. Isometric torque was measured using a dynamometer, and EMG activity was measured using a multichannel EMG system. Measurements were obtained during maximal isometric contraction of the quadriceps femoris muscles at 15-degree increments from 15 to 105 degrees of knee flexion. Measurements were taken before and after 8 weeks of training. RESULTS. Following isometric exercise, increased torque and EMG activity occurred not only at the angle at which subjects exercised, but also at angles in the range of motion at which exercise did occur. Further analyses indicated that exercising in the lengthened position for the quadriceps femoris muscles (90 degrees of knee flexion) produced increased torque across all angles measured and appeared to be the more effective position for transferring strength and EMG activity to adjacent angles following isometric training as compared with the shorter positions of the muscle (30 degrees and 60 degrees of knee flexion). CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION. These findings suggest that an efficient method for increasing isometric knee extension torque and EMG activity throughout the entire range of motion is to exercise with the quadriceps femoris muscles in the lengthened position.
PMID: 8316579 This suggests that isometrics done at the greatest joint angle will, in fact, increase strength throughout the entire range of motion.
I was watching a youtube video recently where the author mentioned why reducing drag is so important and that increasing strength alone, in the absence of reduction in drag, will be an uphill battle because increases in strength alone don't produce nearly the kind of gains that we might hope for.
If one wants to increase strength, I would think that doing, say, faster than race pace 25 yd sprints, or power work with fins or hand paddles, would be a very good way to combine strength work with drag reduction work. I think I notice drag, and address it, much better when I'm doing sprint sets to be honest. When I'm swimming at much less than race pace, I can get sloppy without paying as dear a price.
Just try doing 25yd max effort dolphin kicking or flutter kicking. That is exhausting work, and it actually makes me nauseated sometimes! I think sometimes we prefer dryland because it's *easier*.
I was watching a youtube video recently where the author mentioned why reducing drag is so important and that increasing strength alone, in the absence of reduction in drag, will be an uphill battle because increases in strength alone don't produce nearly the kind of gains that we might hope for.
That's a good point and quite true. I'm sure all of us have seen the body builder types enter the 50 free and do nothing more than pound the water for half a minute. Good form always wins over brawn. Not the other way around.
I think the value in this thread is really for swimmers who might want to implement various forms of strength training to enhance their current performance levels. The gym is something which all athletes can benefit from.
Page 4 of that article talks about supercompensation effect: en.wikipedia.org/.../Supercompensation
I have been using this effect to increase my effectiveness in competition for years, but I never knew what it was called or why it worked. Thanks swimmerb212!
I wish I had my own personal scientist to help me figure out the best way to time workouts and intensity. But I'm starting to get into a groove based on trial, error, and the schedule of my day job!
I think the bottom line is that it's going to take some time, perhaps a year or more to really see the results, but it's worth the effort in the meantime.
All swimmers need to read that article. Thanks for sharing it. I wish you lots of fun on your new lifting program.
Thanks, and you're welcome! I was worried for a minute the thread was getting off topic, but I really hope others get to read that article and get as much out of it as I did.
build strength doing exercises that match or closely match movements in water
Strength imbalances are common in swimmers and should not be reinforced.
A general strength building plan makes sense for masters swimmers because it can correct muscle imbalances, increase proprioception and maintain bone density. These are guaranteed benefits to go along with the more difficult to quantify strength to speed improvements.
Shahboz, your example workout is pretty unbalanced. Jazz's push+pull+squat plan is general, well founded strength training advice.
I don't see any reason to believe in rep range "zones" for different attributes. It's much more important to have an enjoyable workout.
It is for this reason that I like to mix up reps and weights (and to a smaller extent recovery time between sets) over time: to avoid losing motivation when you hit a plateau. Changing to different exercises can also work for this, I suppose.
I don't know whether there are different types of benefits associated with different rep ranges -- others seem to think so but I have no direct experience of this phenomenon, at least as it relates to swimming performance.
I like your thoughts about the (lack of) necessity for working to failure, though certainly I do feel some fatigue at the end of sets (otherwise I'm not sure I'm working hard enough). I also agree with that statements about weights not duplicating the high-rep/low-resistance workouts you get in the water.
I am not so sure that translating strength gains in the weight room to the swimming pool is as straightforward as you stated earlier. I have been wondering lately whether there may be a place in the training cycle -- maybe in the weeks leading into the taper phase -- where you reduce intensity in the weight room and add more strength-related exercises in the water (eg, swimming against resistance -- by using chutes, for example -- or using paddles or doing sets that work more on "explosiveness").
I tried this just informally this past season: I stopped doing weights about 8 weeks out from nationals (training wasn't the only reason for this, there were also some time constraints due to work as well as aching elbows that needed a little break from the weightroom). To compensate I tried to do some of those strength-related exercises I mentioned in the water. I didn't feel any less strong than usual at nationals, and my performances didn't suffer for it either, IMO.
Understand, I don't think that these things can replace weights on an ongoing basis. You just cannot generate the same resistance in the water that you can in the weight room. But I also don't feel the benefits of a good weight program are lost in a mere 1-2 weeks, either, especially if you do power-type things in the pool.
As a related point: opinions about when to stop weights going into taper seem to be all over the map. Some people lift almost up to the meet itself, wanting to feel powerful. Others (I am among them) like 3 weeks or more. Thoughts?
What about extreme angle isometrics? I've done these sporadically -- an extreme angle squat, extreme angle lunge, and an extreme angle step up on a box. The first two you do without weights until you get to 5:00 and then you add weight. The last one you do with DBs on a fairly high box with one foot on the box and only the toe of the other foot on the ground. You only use the lead leg to pull you up; I've heard these are better than single leg squats for increasing leg strength. I like to do the extreme angle isometric squat followed by overhead squats and squat jumps with a bar.
Here's a study on the topic:
Extreme Angle Isometrics:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/.../entrez
Changes in torque and electromyographic activity of the quadriceps femoris muscles following isometric training.Bandy WD, Hanten WP.
Department of Physical Therapy, University of Central Arkansas, Conway 72035-0001.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE. The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of isometric training of the quadriceps femoris muscles, at different joint angles, on torque production and electromyographic (EMG) activity. SUBJECTS. One hundred seven women were randomly assigned to one of four groups. Three groups trained with isometric contractions three times per week at a knee flexion angle of 30, 60, or 90 degrees. The fourth group, which served as a control, did not exercise. METHODS. Isometric torque was measured using a dynamometer, and EMG activity was measured using a multichannel EMG system. Measurements were obtained during maximal isometric contraction of the quadriceps femoris muscles at 15-degree increments from 15 to 105 degrees of knee flexion. Measurements were taken before and after 8 weeks of training. RESULTS. Following isometric exercise, increased torque and EMG activity occurred not only at the angle at which subjects exercised, but also at angles in the range of motion at which exercise did occur. Further analyses indicated that exercising in the lengthened position for the quadriceps femoris muscles (90 degrees of knee flexion) produced increased torque across all angles measured and appeared to be the more effective position for transferring strength and EMG activity to adjacent angles following isometric training as compared with the shorter positions of the muscle (30 degrees and 60 degrees of knee flexion). CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION. These findings suggest that an efficient method for increasing isometric knee extension torque and EMG activity throughout the entire range of motion is to exercise with the quadriceps femoris muscles in the lengthened position.
PMID: 8316579 This suggests that isometrics done at the greatest joint angle will, in fact, increase strength throughout the entire range of motion.
Thanks.I'll give them a try.