What stroke burns the most calories

The doc wanted to see me this week in order to refill a medication prescription. Just after 8 holiday parties, I went in and was weighed as usual. Oh boy. I know I gain during the winter and loose it in the more active summer, but did I need to be weighed right after Christmas? My weight increased so that now for the first time in my life I am considered overweight (but no obese:D), according to the BMI calculation. I have begun watching calories & keeping track of calories in a written log, (which I understand is good for achieving results.) As part of my 'recovery', I am also discovering how to burn calories. So how many calories does each stroke burn? From the internet, in a one hour swim (assume that means swimming continuously) for my weight / age: ..backstroke 651 ..breaststroke 931 ..butterfly 1024 ..freestyle fast 931 ..freestyle moderate 651 (Note to self: 1 pound of body fat = 3500 calories)
  • it is all and only about duration and intensity - and having fun along the way.
  • Heavily-muscled, lean individuals with large bones can be incorrectly labeled as overweight or even obese strictly by virtue of their high BMI. I suspected BMI was only one factor is determining 'correct' weight. After all, my doctor was not overly concerned with my weight. Still, my bones and muscle did not grow over the holidays (or over the past years for that matter,) but my weight did. I guess a little calorie accountability is in order.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    According to my heart rate monitor, I burn more calories on a 100 IM than 100 free. However it told me that I burnt more calories on Tuesday doing 4800yds than I did today doing 5000yds of similar workout mix. :dunno: FWIW I always feel I get a better all-round workout if I include some IM work, and it makes things more interesting.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    The exercise calorie burn numbers are generalized and may be reasonably accurate for you -- or maybe they won't. Actual calorie burn will vary by your skill, speed, water temperature, your flotation, your conditioning, and myriad other factors. BMI is a statistic but may not be an accurate estimate of body composition / body fat. If you get dehydrated, your pounds and BMI will drop but it isn't achieving your overall objective. Heavily-muscled, lean individuals with large bones can be incorrectly labeled as overweight or even obese strictly by virtue of their high BMI. Measuring your food and logging calories consumed does help keep you accountable to your caloric intake; keeping an exercise log does help you see what your expenditures are. After collecting some data you'll be able to fine-tune and see what works for you and what doesn't. You may find motivation using a tape measure to record your waist circumference; and a body fat scale to see if pounds lost are due to improved body composition.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    I got Wii Fit for Christmas and it told me I am a big fatso. :mad:
  • So how many calories does each stroke burn? From the internet, in a one hour swim (assume that means swimming continuously) for my weight / age: ..backstroke 651 ..breaststroke 931 ..butterfly 1024 ..freestyle fast 931 ..freestyle moderate 651 (Note to self: 1 pound of body fat = 3500 calories) Do you recall the source of these numbers? I'd like to take a look.
  • I suspected BMI was only one factor is determining 'correct' weight. After all, my doctor was not overly concerned with my weight. Still, my bones and muscle did not grow over the holidays (or over the past years for that matter,) but my weight did. I guess a little calorie accountability is in order. Your weight can also grow if you lift weights and/or do other types of weight-bearing exercises. I'd say swimming will also increase overall muscle mass to some degree over time (and I'm sure others can chime in). Whenever I see people I haven't seen for a while, they usually comment that my upper body looks bigger. Over the past 2 years, my weight has mostly stayed within 5-10 pounds. Yet my body fat % (as measured on a scale with bare feet) has dropped about 5%. I know these scales aren't 100% accurate, but I look for overall trends. A smaller waistline can also be a good trend (mine seems to keep shrinking).
  • Do you recall the source of these numbers? I'd like to take a look. I found several sources for information to compare. I posted stats from this one, which was the easiest to copy: www.nutristrategy.com/activitylist3.htm This also looked more accurate since it used specific weight: www.everydayhealth.com/calories-burned-swimming.htm
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    The best weight control: do not eat or drink any food with added sugar, nothing fried, whole grain cereals! Yeap!!! it sounds as if “life’s flavor” is taken away:D
  • I think if you take a nap, that's like 400 calories. I would think the stroke that burns the most calories is the one you least want to do. tee hee hee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 2 3 4