If I could just learn how to breathe....

Former Member
Former Member
If I could just learn how to breathe I think I would be a pretty good swimmer. After several months of indoor lessons last winter, my ten year old son can swim a perfect bilateral breathing freestyle. And now he is encouraging his old man, (58 years old) to learn how to swim too. I have been looking around and I found this article I will paste here. I tried to blow bubbles through my nose in a big bowl of water on the kitchen table but my nose refused to cooperate. So I got real determined and really tried to force air out my nose but I could feel the air go into my stomach instead! I know I am scared:afraid:and there is some involuntary mechanism that diverts air into my stomach. Have any of you heard of anyone overcoming this problem? Thanks, - Steve from Kansas Here's the article: Active.com > Swimming > Breathing Basics: Getting Comfortable
Breathing Basics: Getting Comfortable www.active.com/.../BowlPractice_150.jpg Practicing your breathing in a mixing bowl is a unique way to perfect your breathing skills. Comment Share Email Print Save By Terry Laughlin Total Immersion Among the major differences between swimming and all land-based sports is that breathing in the water is a skill, and a fairly advanced one at that. In weeks following the opening of our swim studio in New Paltz, New York, I spent many hours teaching in an Endless Pool, where proximity to my students allowed me to observe how essential breathing comfort is to their progress and success. This has convinced me that, until breathing becomes routine, effective focus on other aspects of the stroke is impossible. But once they master breathing, other skills follow much more rapidly. Securing Your Airways The number one source of tension and inhibition for new swimmers is the very real fear that water will go up your nose or down your air passages. I see this fear manifest while trying to teach balance positions—which are the non-negotiable first step to good technique. Keeping most of the head submerged while swimming is essential to good balance, but this brings the water perilously close to nose and mouth. When someone rotates from a nose-down balance position to a nose-up position—the first step in learning efficient breathing mechanics—they have difficulty completing the movement because they're afraid they'll inhale water instead of air. People respond to both fears the same: lifting their head abruptly so the nose and mouth will be at a "safer" distance from the surface. And the instant they do, precious balance and smoothness are lost. Here are some simple steps, which include the Gruneberg Method, that you can take to feel more secure about getting all the air you need, while minimizing your chances of inhaling water: 1. Practice breathing in a good-sized mixing bowl—at least twice the circumference of your face—filled with warm water. If you have a mirror that can fit into the bottom of the bowl, put that in too. Then try the following: Dip your chin into the water and leave it there while you breathe in through your mouth and out through mouth and nose. Observe how your breath ruffles the surface. Continue for 30 seconds or more until this feels almost meditative. Next, lightly touch your nose and lips to the surface and practice inhaling through the small space at the corners of your mouth. In the mirror, notice the "blotting" created where your nose and lips touch the water. Play at this with a spirit of curiosity for about a minute or until you feel almost "bored" with it. www.active.com/.../Submerged_175.jpg With goggles on, lower your face into the water, keeping your mouth open but without exhaling (see right). Notice how natural air pressure keeps water from entering your nostrils or mouth. As you lift your face, notice how you can inhale easily, even with water dripping around your mouth and nose. In this and subsequent exercises, try to inhale with the tip of your nose still touching the water. Repeat as above, but this time bubble gently from your nose. Watch in the mirror, trying to keep your bubbles small and quiet. The smaller and quieter they are, the longer you'll be able to sustain one exhale, before lifting to inhale again. Repeat this but bubbling only from your mouth. When you can do each of the above in a calm and contained manner, advance to "rhythmic breathing." Lower your face and bubble out for a count of four or five-one-thousand. Lift and inhale for a count of one-one-thousand. Lower and repeat. For an interesting challenge, alternate between mouth bubbles on one exhale and nose bubbles on the next. Your goal is to inhale with the tip of your nose—and perhaps even your nostrils—still in the water and your mouth barely clearing it. Repeat until you develop a relaxed and seamless rhythm. 2. Repeat the final exercise in shallow water at the pool. (Precede it with the other exercises if you wish.) Crouching with hands resting on knees or the pool gutter, dip your face for a sustained bubbling exhale (four to five one-thousands), then lift it to inhale with minimal clearance. Repeat until this feels effortless and meditative. Its calming effect will help you resume swimming with much more sense of command in breathing and everything else. 3. After a few minutes of the above, progress to bobbing. Start with shallow and brief immersion—just dipping to your hairline—and work your way to longer, deeper immersion, focusing on sustained steady bubbling. Bob up, beginning to inhale as soon as your mouth clears the water. This time don't worry about keeping your nose at the surface, but focus on becoming comfortable getting air even as water cascades down from your head across your face. Then without pause, bob back down again. 4. Swim some easy 25-yard repeats. On these 25s, let your need for air entirely dictate the speed and rhythm of your stroke. If it helps, count off your exhales and inhales by one-thousands, as you did in the bowl. For your rest interval between 25s, take several deep, slow cleansing breaths. When you can repeat 25s, with a sufficient sense of ease that you need only three cleansing breaths before starting the next, you can progress to 50-yard repeats.
  • Honestly - I would just do what is comfortable for you. I usually do a combination of the two except on the wall where I push through my nose so the water does run up in to my sinuses -Michael P.
  • I might try proceeding to step 2. Something about putting my face in a bowl of water seems uncomfortable and unnatural. Try just dunking down under the water with your head in a vertical position first, holding on to the side of the pool. My guess (and it's just a guess) is that you'll feel more comfortable doing this than sticking your head in a bowl.
  • I think I blow more air out of my mouth than my nose. Only on flip turns do you have to use your nose.
  • I think I blow more air out of my mouth than my nose. Only on flip turns do you have to use your nose. I think the same is true for me.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    Steve, There is nothing wrong with private swim lessons. Really, the people who teach little kids can help you too. You are just a little kid who can touch the bottom of the pool, which makes their job easier. I think that sticking your face in a bowl of water is a little scary. It is June, is there not a large body of water that you can walk into in Kansas that you can stick your face into to do your breath test? The only reason you need to blow air out of your nose is to keep water out. If your face is in the water and water is not going up your nose, you can successfully move on. Look at it this way. You are 50% responsible for your sons genetic swimming ability, he has already gone to the trouble of proving that you are genetically able to swim, you just need to go to the trouble to learn. And there is no rush, if you have taken 58 years to learn, what is a few more weeks easing into it?
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    I've been swimming seven years and am still learning more about how to breathe properly. It may help you to understand that breathing while swimming is hard. This sounds obvious, since if you breathe at the wrong time, you get a mouthful of water. But in any athletic endeavor, it is important to relax your neck muscles and maximize the amount of oxygen you bring into your lungs. It's even harder when you swim because of the natural reluctance to conduct any part of breathing while your face is in the water. That means you have to learn how to breathe in out of the water and learn how to breathe out when your face is in the water. To me, the idea that you have to know when to breathe is something that makes swimming interesting. When I'm doing any other exercise, I think how much easier it is to breathe when you don't have to worry about making a mistake.
  • If it's water up your nose that most worries you... try a noseplug and focus on breathing in and out of your mouth first. Many great swimmers use noseplugs.
  • Redbird has a good go to 1st with the nose plug. I also blow mostly out my mouth , with just enough air out the nose to keep water from coming in.
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    Thank you, for all your replies and suggestions. I will keep working on it. I am pretty determined and I tried freestyle breathing on Saturdsy. I did manage to take two breaths but my nose and sinuses started stinging really badly. The Sinuses sting below my eyes. It was so miserable that I had to stop. But on Sunday, it didn't hurt so badly. But it makes my nose run. My son came to me and very confidentially told me that I needed to wipe my nose! Ha! And my son told me I am lifing my head up too high when I breathe, just like I used to tell him! It takes me about 2 whole seconds to take a breath to get comfortable enough to put my head back down. So tonight when I breathe, I am going to roll on my side, into "my sweet spot" that Terry Laughlin speaks about in his videos. I will try to get composed on my side. The sweet spot is swimming on your side, powered only by your legs. Terry Laughlin recommends going back into freestyle after you regain composure. Perhaps I can keep this up and somehow gradually learn how to relax and keep water out of my nose by learning to keep exaling pressure on my nose. I have seen the little kids who act like I am acting now and they progress slowly, so it will probably take some time for me too. I will keep you informed. Thanks, - Steve from Kansas
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    I've been swimming for about seven months now and I'm just beginning to fill somewhat comfortable exhaling air out of my nose. As others have suggested above, you should probably use a nose clip and just breath through your mouth. That will also help you, if like me, you're susceptible to sinus infections. Keep trying, it does get easier eventually.
1 2