Poll: should Libby Lenton have the record

Former Member
Former Member
The FINA rules say no but not considering the rulebook, should Libby Lenton's 52.99 go in the record books. There has been alot of debate on this in the other thread. What do you think?
Parents
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    .... Especially as a woman accused (rightly or not) of drafting off of Phelps. You (not you ensignada, so let me rephrase that): One can only accuse someone of something illegal, or not allowed. As far as I know, drafting has yet to be outlawed. (And if outlawed, the only way they can enforce it is to have every swimmer swim all alone, since according to the Laws of Physics, waves propagate (diminishing but propagate) and if you take the calculation "ad infinitum", the wave created by somebody two lanes away from you is -I believe- equal to the square root of the draft off the lane right next to you. So, theoretically (on paper) lane 1 could feel the effect of the (draft) waves from lane 8 (the difference would be measurable when they have electronic timers capable of timing to the 1/1000000th of a second). Thus, I don't believe anyone was accusing her of drafting but explaining why she did the time she did. I think she's already demonstrated a boatload of class. Amen to that!
Reply
  • Former Member
    Former Member
    .... Especially as a woman accused (rightly or not) of drafting off of Phelps. You (not you ensignada, so let me rephrase that): One can only accuse someone of something illegal, or not allowed. As far as I know, drafting has yet to be outlawed. (And if outlawed, the only way they can enforce it is to have every swimmer swim all alone, since according to the Laws of Physics, waves propagate (diminishing but propagate) and if you take the calculation "ad infinitum", the wave created by somebody two lanes away from you is -I believe- equal to the square root of the draft off the lane right next to you. So, theoretically (on paper) lane 1 could feel the effect of the (draft) waves from lane 8 (the difference would be measurable when they have electronic timers capable of timing to the 1/1000000th of a second). Thus, I don't believe anyone was accusing her of drafting but explaining why she did the time she did. I think she's already demonstrated a boatload of class. Amen to that!
Children
No Data