Anybody else out there detect out there a petulant tone from Ian Thorpe on the subject of Michael Phelps?
Context:
Back in 2002, Thorpe was toying with the idea of swimming some non-free events in order to achieve a Spitz-lie medal haul in 2004. People pointed to his background in backstroke and possiblity of swimming IM as possible avenues. He wisely ducked out of backstroke when it became apparent that the 100 back is one of strongest events in the world right now.
He then tried to the 200 IM, before Phelps emerged on the scene in late 2002/2003 an event that was dominated by 28 year-old Europeans but then got trounced by Phelps in this event at Worlds.
Phelps performance at Worlds in 2003 overshadowed Thorpe and the great Aussie start shelved his plans to branch out. He's now aiming for 200/400 gold and is a darkhouse candidate for 100 gold.
Recent Snipes from Thorpe:
1) When asked about the probability of Phelps hauling in multiple medals he retorted it's "impossible" (o.k. that's a defensible position) and further more "no one should even try". (sounds like he's jealous to me). Phelps to his credited responded, "Spitz did it once" and "he's talking about himself not me".
2) Recently when asked if he was worried about Phelps in the 200 free, Thorpe's reply ..."we're worrried about the whoe field". He's not giving Phelps any credit for challenging him in an event that the 19 year old is really the underdog but wants to race it for the challenge and experience.
3) Now Thorpe is smearing the reptuation of his unnamed competitors by claiming that "I've raced against competitors that are using drugs" and "the sport is not clean".
What kind of champion is Thorpe? He's not helping our sport with his attitude. Why not welcome the competition and be gracious about it. Why not wish Phelps good luck but tell him that he'll have his hands full beating him in the 200. If he has evidence about illegal drug use why not name names and not hide behind blanket accusations. And let's remind the Thorpedo if Phelps does accomplish his medal haul there is no crying in swimming.
BTW, for the record the US men beat the Australian men in all three relays.
PS: The Aussie women's team is the strongest ever and will likely beat the US women in 2 of the 3 relays.
Parents
Former Member
It will be very hard for Phelps to win all of the races he has entered because of the new format with the qualifying & Semi's. If he does it will be great. We must remember though that the total number of races he will be swimmin gis far more than what Spitz had to do.
Also, Thorpe's overall form is much better in the free. Look at how phelps screws the lightbulb and doesn't drop the pinkie when he first catches the water, esp. with his left hand. that creates drag, uses more time & creats drag. Both are probably the best swimmers around right now. But both have trememdous competition.
It will be an exciting competition. Hopefully, it will spark some true interest in swimming in this country. the real debate seems to me to be why are so many colleges dropping swimming as a sport in the USA. In Australia, the number of clubs, the dominant organizations through which people compete, has dramatically increased over the last 20 years.
It will be very hard for Phelps to win all of the races he has entered because of the new format with the qualifying & Semi's. If he does it will be great. We must remember though that the total number of races he will be swimmin gis far more than what Spitz had to do.
Also, Thorpe's overall form is much better in the free. Look at how phelps screws the lightbulb and doesn't drop the pinkie when he first catches the water, esp. with his left hand. that creates drag, uses more time & creats drag. Both are probably the best swimmers around right now. But both have trememdous competition.
It will be an exciting competition. Hopefully, it will spark some true interest in swimming in this country. the real debate seems to me to be why are so many colleges dropping swimming as a sport in the USA. In Australia, the number of clubs, the dominant organizations through which people compete, has dramatically increased over the last 20 years.
