Swimmers and coaches often set workout targets like 90% effort or 95% effort for practice swims. I've always found these directives to be less than useful. What is "90% effort"? I've taken to setting time targets of race time plus a certain percentage. For example one could specify the set:
5x(100 free @ race + 15%)/2:00.
That is, five 100 free swims on the 2:00 (120 sec.) interval with a target time of race time + 15%. (This would be a painful lactate production set in my estimation.)
Based on my own experience, I constructed this chart giving qualitative descriptions of the effort level associated with a practice swim from a push to achieve race time plus a percentage:
7283
A few notes:
This would correspond to the effort level of the first swim in a group. Obviously even race +25% will constitute a very hard effort after you have done a lot of them.
Generally, it appears to be easier to swim at race pace + x% for longer swims.
It is easier to swim near race pace for backstroke than freestyle. I suspect that this is simply due to the fact that a freestyle dive start gives more of an advantage over a push than a backstroke race start.
I pose the following two questions to the forum community:
1) How do these effort levels compare with your experience? I'd love to see similar charts for other swimmers.
2) How much time do you spend in practice at each effort level? This will certainly depend on the time of the season. Early in the season I expect one might do a lot of "blue" swims up to some yellow, whereas later in the season one needs to spend a lot more time in yellow with frequent excursions into in the "red zone".
Swimmers and coaches often set workout targets like 90% effort or 95% effort for practice swims. I've always found these directives to be less than useful. What is "90% effort"? I've taken to setting time targets of race time plus a certain percentage.
I was reading a study on this two days ago, they found that as a group 90% effort was faster than 80% effort for example. But on an intraindividual basis, a coach prescribed 90% effort wasn't faster than a coach prescribed 80% effort.
I agree with you, there is too much variability in those descriptions for me. As a coach, one of the biggest problems we have s communicating, the message we think we are sending is not the message being received. What I think is 90% and what you think is 90% can be wildly different things.
I use something similar but I follow through with monthly time trials and publish the results so that people aren't guessing at the proper paces.
I calculate critical swim speeds from the time trials and the en1, en2, and en3 sets are based off of critical pace. The sp1 and sp2 sets are based off of 200 or 100 time trial day times. SP3 sets are just all out.
So for me a set might be 12 x 100 (:15 rest) at 0:05 / 100 slower than critical pace
Or a sprint set might be
50 (:20) at 200 time trial day pace
50 (1:00) at same pace
200 swim down between rounds
Swimmers and coaches often set workout targets like 90% effort or 95% effort for practice swims. I've always found these directives to be less than useful. What is "90% effort"? I've taken to setting time targets of race time plus a certain percentage.
I was reading a study on this two days ago, they found that as a group 90% effort was faster than 80% effort for example. But on an intraindividual basis, a coach prescribed 90% effort wasn't faster than a coach prescribed 80% effort.
I agree with you, there is too much variability in those descriptions for me. As a coach, one of the biggest problems we have s communicating, the message we think we are sending is not the message being received. What I think is 90% and what you think is 90% can be wildly different things.
I use something similar but I follow through with monthly time trials and publish the results so that people aren't guessing at the proper paces.
I calculate critical swim speeds from the time trials and the en1, en2, and en3 sets are based off of critical pace. The sp1 and sp2 sets are based off of 200 or 100 time trial day times. SP3 sets are just all out.
So for me a set might be 12 x 100 (:15 rest) at 0:05 / 100 slower than critical pace
Or a sprint set might be
50 (:20) at 200 time trial day pace
50 (1:00) at same pace
200 swim down between rounds