Should swimming instruction be mandatory as part of physical education/gym classes in public schools?
The idea for this question arose from a comment made by someone else last week in another thread that had gone off topic, and was reinforced for me personally this past weekend when the 9-year old nephew (non-swimmer) of a close friend of mine nearly drowned (but for his observant and fast acting uncle) and again this morning with tragic news reported in a local newspaper of the drowning of a child in a neighbor’s back yard pool.
I believe there was a time when swimming instruction was fairly common in PE in public schools. Although there was no swimming instruction as part of gym classes when I was in school, we had a free swim (recreation, but no instruction) as part of gym class in Jr. High (a generation ago). Moreover, the university I attended required all students regardless of major to pass a very basic swimming test in order to get their bachelor's degree. That requirement went the way of the dinosaurs about the time I graduated. (I read somewhere that Harvard imposed the requirement (now abandoned, I believe) after one of its students (Widener, for whom the library is named) drowned when the Titanic sank). I am not aware of any colleges that require this today, and I haven’t heard of any local school districts (at least in the metropolitan Boston area) that require students to learn to swim. (I think a few of the more affluent Massachusetts towns that have pools may offer swimming, but as an elective only).
So, what do you think? Does your school district offer or require swimming instruction today? Should it be required? (The utopian/libertarian side of me recoils at the thought of mandating anything, but the pragmatic/utilitarian side often prevails). I imagine the cost of constructing pools would be the major issue, but with all the money that gets wasted on everything else it would not be out of the realm of possibilities if the will were there.
Thinking back on of all time wasted on the marginally useful activities they had us do in PE/gym class in school, the idea seems even more attractive. Teaching swimming would be an opportunity to teach something really, really useful--not only something that could be life-saving, but that could also provide a life time of healthy activity. (I'm reminded of Paul Simon's lyrics (dating myself): "When I think back on all the crap I learned in high school, it's a wonder I can even think at all.").
I wish we did have this requirement. A young man who just graduated from the high school where I teach just drowned in a back-yard pool when he slipped into the deep end and couldn't get out. Tragic. And so avoidable.
In my town we have 4 comprehensive high schools, a technical high school and several smaller alternative schools - none of them have pools. Every single one of the city pools has been shut down due to lack of funds. I take that back - one of them was rebuilt and reopened. We have two state pools in town that are booked solid for swim lessons within the first five minutes of the sign-up table opening.
We also have at least 4 private/parochial high schools - only one of them (a pricy boarding school) has a pool.
The private facilities/clubs are priced far far beyond what a working class parent could afford.
If there were to be a requirement for high school graduation, I'm not sure how we would implement it.
That said, I'm still shocked at how few of my students know how to swim - we have a beautiful Boys & GIrls Club that costs $20 a year to join and it offers free swimming lessons from September to June. The downtown Y is free for our students through the city health initiative.
We have at least one drowning a year and it's just so heart-breaking.
So no we don't have mandatory swim classes in our schools but I desperately wish we did - I don't want to go to another funeral for a former student ever again.
I wish we did have this requirement. A young man who just graduated from the high school where I teach just drowned in a back-yard pool when he slipped into the deep end and couldn't get out. Tragic. And so avoidable.
In my town we have 4 comprehensive high schools, a technical high school and several smaller alternative schools - none of them have pools. Every single one of the city pools has been shut down due to lack of funds. I take that back - one of them was rebuilt and reopened. We have two state pools in town that are booked solid for swim lessons within the first five minutes of the sign-up table opening.
We also have at least 4 private/parochial high schools - only one of them (a pricy boarding school) has a pool.
The private facilities/clubs are priced far far beyond what a working class parent could afford.
If there were to be a requirement for high school graduation, I'm not sure how we would implement it.
That said, I'm still shocked at how few of my students know how to swim - we have a beautiful Boys & GIrls Club that costs $20 a year to join and it offers free swimming lessons from September to June. The downtown Y is free for our students through the city health initiative.
We have at least one drowning a year and it's just so heart-breaking.
So no we don't have mandatory swim classes in our schools but I desperately wish we did - I don't want to go to another funeral for a former student ever again.
